Date: 2013-06-30 12:52 am (UTC)
frameacloud: A white dragon with its tail in a knot. (Heraldry transparent)
From: [personal profile] frameacloud
Other than creationists, there are a lot of authors who argue that dragons are based on vague reconstructions of extinct animal fossils. I haven't even seen proof of that connection, though. I think that connection is speculative. I would think that wyverns look so much like pterosaurs that some ancient person must have found some really sweet pterosaur fossils, but I haven't heard of anybody proving that connection. I've heard the argument that gryphons (yeah, not quite dragons, never mind) could have been fanciful reconstructions of protoceratops fossils (a four-legged animal with a beak). While it's possible and even likely that the ancients must have found dinosaur bones, we don't know that the ancients had a nice protoceratops fossil and decided it was a gryphon. The similarity between a protoceratops and a gryphon could still be coincidental.

The only example I know of where we know for sure that a specific dragon myth was based on a fossil-- and it's not even a dinosaur fossil-- is the linnorm of Austria, because the people in question displayed a weird skull and said it was a dragon's, and kept the skull, so moderns were able to identify it as a rhino skull.

Maybe we never based dragons on dinosaurs. Maybe we reconstruct dinosaurs to look dragon-like. Out of wishful thinking. What else could an unknown large reptile be, but the thing from our myths and preconceptions?

[Edited a minute later to add:] Wait no I am so stupid I forgot! We do know for sure that the "dragon bones" used in traditional Chinese medicine are fossils, and a lot of them are dinosaur fossils. But they get all ground up into powder, not reconstructed. So I don't know how people would figure that those bones would look like reptiles. ...This is what I get for posting about my favorite subject just off the top of my head, without consulting any of my notes.
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting

Profile

otherkinnews: A centaur reading a newspaper. (Default)
Otherkin News

About

Otherkin News is a collaborative, volunteer-run blog for sharing news for otherkin, therianthropes, fictionfolk, plural systems, and all sorts of alterhumans. You can join and post here about current events in our communities and newspaper articles that are about us. The person moderating this is [personal profile] frameacloud. Everyone is welcome to subscribe and explore our tags.

May 2025

S M T W T F S
    123
456789 10
111213141516 17
18192021222324
25262728293031

Most Popular Tags